NEWS TALK RADIO Our Hosts
Powered by: Townhall.com
Sign Up
Monday, January 14, 2008
Carol Platt Liebau :: Townhall.com Columnist
Clinton "Turns Back the Clock" on Female Leaders for Her Own Political Gain
by Carol Platt Liebau
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
How did you find out about WGKA?





In the Capitol rotunda, there’s a piece of marble etched with the faces of famous women like Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton. But part of it will remain conspicuously untouched – bare until the image of the first female President is carved upon it. Given her victory last week in the New Hampshire primary, it’s entirely possible that Hillary Clinton’s will be the face that joins Anthony’s and Stanton’s on the sculpture.

For some time, Hillary has embraced (some would even say exploited) her status as the first female ever to be a serious contender for the presidency, presenting herself as a champion for all women. But just as Bill Clinton sold out almost every political or ideological ally at one time or another for his own political advantage, Hillary is poised to do the same thing -- by engaging in behavior that resurrects the worst stereotypes about female leaders, even as it advances her own quest for power.

Commentators far and wide have acknowledged the political benefits to Clinton of her emotional display during a meeting with New Hampshire voters after her third place finish in the Iowa caucuses. The New York Daily News’ Helen Kennedy observed that Hillary’s “smashing primary success Tuesday came after showing a little female vulnerability, emotion and weakness.” A member of the Obama team credits Hillary’s “choking up” for her come-from-behind victory in the nation’s first primary.

They may well be right. Hillary’s weepiness offered a glimpse at the inner life of a candidate who too often seems unattractive – almost inhuman – in her hectoring, rigidity and relentless pursuit of power. But although her tears helped Clinton as an individual candidate, they certainly make life more difficult for any woman who follows in her footsteps. After all, it's fair for voters to ask: If a tough old bird like Hillary dissolves into tears when the going gets tough, what woman wouldn't?

The behavior that some believe clinched Clinton's New Hampshire victory raised other serious questions: If Hillary is tearing up publicly over a single political defeat in the earliest phases of the presidential election process, how exactly would she (or any woman) handle the dispiriting setbacks that inevitably come with holding the most powerful office in the world? And is an image of “female vulnerability” – however politically advantageous to Hillary personally, now or in the future – really what Americans want to project to Islamofascists around the world?

Nor were her tears the only setback Hillary dealt the cause of women in politics last week. When two men – dolts, to be sure – disrupted a Clinton event by raising signs and chanting “Iron my shirt!” Hillary immediately responded with some bitterness, “"Oh, the remnants of sexism, alive and well tonight.” With that, she immediately lent credence to the all-too-widely held suspicion that lurking within even the most powerful professional woman is a humorless feminist, ready (even eager) to denounce men as sexist pigs.

For Hillary herself, it made good political sense to play the victim, and her gambit to elicit sympathy and fellow-feeling from women in the crowd seems to have worked. But how much more admirable would she have been if her reply had reflected a mature recognition that some people – men and women alike – are simply idiots, to be dismissed with grace and good humor? She could easily have demonstrated a particularly female kind of resilience had she joked, "Well, it certainly looks like someone needs to iron your shirts – just for starters – and, by the way, when’s the last time you guys showered?!”

Ultimately, no one can justly claim the mantle of a feminist pioneer if she ends up creating more, not fewer, barriers for the women who will one day seek to succeed her. After all, part of the reason that Anthony and Stanton have been immortalized in marble in the nation’s Capitol is because they actually succeeded in improving the quality of life not so much for themselves as for those who came after them.

As Hillary uses every sniffle and lecture to bring her one step closer to the job she’s yearned for so fiercely and so long, it would be good if she thought about the kind of trail she’s blazing for the next female presidential hopeful, Democrat or Republican. But then, thinking of others has never been the Clinton way.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Carol Platt Liebau is an attorney, political commentator and guest radio talk show host based near Los Angeles. Learn more about her new book, "Prude: How the Sex-Obsessed Culture Hurts Young Women (and America, Too!)" here.

Be the first to read Carol Platt Liebau's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Subject: Hillary may...
Hillary may be able to play the female card and she may be able to tear up and, as Marlon
Brando said in the Godfather, "cry like a woman,"~~
but one thing she can't do is shake Old Bill off her trail. And Old Bill is like a turd that won't flush. They're a team, don't you see? Why
do you think they are called Billary?

PS
Wild Bill will sink her politically. Read: Titanic.

suzerose
Obviously reading comprehension is not one of your acquired skills. It was the missus clinton who made those claims about what some shrink told her about bubba's behavior. That the missus clinton has been bubba's primary defender, enabler for his behavior and his doormat doesn't assure those of us on the right that she will stand up to bubba should she get elected. We on the right have a problem with the socialist missus clinton and her narcissist husband retuning to the white house and running the country. Bubba was overall a failure as president who wagged his finger at us and lied about his behavior. He got others to lie for him and got impeached for surborning perjury. At what point will you leftists understand america doesn't need a failed president, his enabler socialist wife returning to the white house. Deflecting your argument to inquire about my personal life is again a very pathetic argument. Why not make an attempt to defend electing the missus clinton. She is running that she is a woman as her qualifier. When the going gets rough she reverts to playing a victim. Her latest ploy was getting dewy eyed. She has her husband telling the country she is a world class agent for change and the most intelligent and gifted person of this generation. Yet the clintons when asked to produce a paper trail concerning her great white house achievements and her involvement as a policy maker refuse to release anything to back up the claim. If she had anything to back up these claims one would think she would be offering them as ready proof. But obviously you are incapable of asking such questions. Being bubba's wife is not a qualifier to be president. The left can't understand this but accepts her lies concerning her trumped up resume
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation: