NEWS TALK RADIO Our Hosts
Powered by: Townhall.com
Sign Up
Monday, July 14, 2008
Carol Platt Liebau :: Townhall.com Columnist
Would Barack Obama Play Politics With Babies’ Lives?
by Carol Platt Liebau
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
How did you find out about WGKA?





In a little-noticed maneuver, on June 17, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid introduced a bill on behalf of its sole sponsor, Barack Obama – who was, apparently, unavailable. S. 3142 is the “Preventing Stillbirth and SUID Act of 2008,” and it authorizes the modest (in governmental terms) sum of $10,000,000 to “enhance public health activities related to stillbirth and sudden unexpected infant death.”

That’s a laudable objective, of course. After a pregnancy full of dreams and eager anticipation, bearing a stillborn child is every mother’s nightmare. And SIDS – a sudden infant death syndrome where young babies die unexpectedly without any apparent reason – is a possibility that haunts all new parents. It’s just that Obama’s sudden interest in this topic and his sponsorship of S. 3142 is almost impossible to reconcile with his opposition as an Illinois state senator to a law intended to protect infants’ lives.

The Illinois state law simply defined a live "homo sapiens" – one who had completely emerged from his or her mother with a “beating heart, pulsation of the umbilical cord or definite movement of voluntary muscles"– as a "'person,' 'human being,' 'child' and 'individual.'” The bill was designed to protect babies born prematurely and in need of care, as well as those who had been born alive during an attempt to abort them. But Obama opposed the legislation (voting “present,” and later, “no”) on the grounds that the legislation could “undermine Roe v. Wade.”

Shortly thereafter, the U.S. Senate unanimously passed the Born Alive Infant Protection Bill – with wording nearly identical to the Illinois state statute Obama had opposed – with the blessing of the National Abortion Rights Action League and pro-abortion stalwarts like Ted Kennedy and Barbara Boxer. The federal bill made it clear that the legislation had no impact on Roe v. Wade. The state bill was subsequently reintroduced in Illinois with the federal language specifically addressing concerns about Roe. Although accounts differ, Obama – who now chaired the state senate committee where the legislation had been referred – either voted against it once again, or allowed it to die over the objections of its supporters.

Even from the outset, Obama’s rationale for opposing the infant protection legislation was flawed. As a constitutional law professor would certainly know, an Illinois state statute cannot, in any meaningful way, “undermine” a federal constitutional right that has been clearly enunciated by the Supreme Court (if there were ever deemed to be a conflict between the two, the state statute would have to fall). But what’s even more revealing is that for Obama, the bill’s speculative, abstract impact on abortion rights outweighed facts before him about living babies apparently being left without medical care to die -- including testimony from a nurse who had held an infant born alive after an abortion for 45 minutes before the baby finally expired.

That’s why it’s raises eyebrows when Barack Obama suddenly emerges as the Senate champion of preventing stillbirths and “sudden unexpected infant death” (emphasis added). It seems that, for him, the adjective “unexpected” makes all the difference.

Given Obama’s recent, transparent efforts to move to the center on a variety of issues, it’s hard not to suspect that he’s using S.3142 to blunt the obvious callousness of his previous abortion-rights extremism. Would Barack Obama really play politics with babies’ lives?

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Carol Platt Liebau is an attorney, political commentator and guest radio talk show host based near Los Angeles. Learn more about her new book, "Prude: How the Sex-Obsessed Culture Hurts Young Women (and America, Too!)" here.

Be the first to read Carol Platt Liebau's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Subject: One more serious problem with McCain
The current entitlement laws are debt-bombs which will FORCE huge increases in government spending if they are not modified. The Congress--House and Senate--will be strongly Dem. McCain gives every indication that he will resume the same pattern we had last time we had a Republican Pres and a Dem Congress--combative partisan gridlock, which ultimately led to the rise of Ross Perot as the anti-gridlock candidate. Obama may or may not be able to get Congress to cooperate on entitlements, but McCain certainly will not.

Government bankruptcy and subsequent rapid near-total devaluation of our currency will cause a lot more American deaths than 9111.

McCain
Now that McCain has flip-flopped on torture, he can flip-flop on anything. I literally would not be surprised now if he flip-flopped on basic issues--if he started supporting child-labor or China's one-child-per-family forced-abortion policy. The only question would be what benefit he would be hoping to gain by doing so.

Actually I take it back, there is still one flip-flop of his that would surprise me--if he did anything against the interests of his masters in the military/gov't-pork industry. What President Eisenhower called the Military-Industrial Complex.

He says he wants to cut Defense, but he's obviously lying--he supports SDI (which used to have other names) even though he know we're many years' and many billions of dollars' worth of basic science and new technology development away from even being able to think seriously about a system that could shoot down an incoming ICBM under any but the most controlled demonstration conditions. Pure military pork justified by a remote fantasy. Remember when Dr. Edward Teller told President Reagan we could shoot commie missles out of the sky with x-ray lasers?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!